Tested the A50 Gen 5 and returned it, along with a Maxwell, keeping an Atlas Air for its far wider soundstage.
Quick note: Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you). Keeps the lights on!
Reviews
Add your reviewSort: NewestMost helpful
Tried hard to like their A50 Gen 5, which pushed them toward buying a DAC and real headphones.
Found the A50 Gen 5 really muddy with too much bass and preferred a Fractal Scape, though the Astro's mic is better.
Their A50 Gen 5 keeps cutting out in games, and switching from game to voice channels bricks their other USB devices on a laptop.
After the Arctis Nova Pro, BlackShark V3 Pro and Stealth Pro, they settled on the A50 for hearing footsteps in Warzone.
This returning Astro user is sending back the A50 Gen 5 because its base station makes charging a struggle.
“The base station is one of the worst things ive ever experienced. You have to aim and move the headset around multiple times to make sure its charging.”
Having tried the top gaming headsets, this user rates the Astro A50 Gen 5 best in class, with the best sound and a mic that rivals USB mics.
“Astro A50 gen 5 is best in class, sounds the best and also has the best mic for discord.”
A buyer of the Astro A50 Gen 5 finds it very comfortable for hours of gaming, with excellent sound quality and a design they like.
“they’re very comfortable and after hours of gaming, they do not hurt my head at all like past headphones of mine have”
An Astro A50 Gen 5 owner says the headband cracked and bent within the first year despite careful use.
“I had the gen 5’s and the head band broke within the first year and I’ve always been incredibly careful with my headsets.”
An Astro A50 Gen 5 owner says the flip mic stopped holding its position within 4 months and the charging dock takes trial and error.
“I have the A50 Gen 5. Rarely use it. Within 4 months the flip mic won’t hold its position.”
An Astro A50 Gen 5 owner finds its imaging fine and its graphene drivers very clear even with boosted bass.
“I have the A50 gen 5 and it does perfectly fine with imaging.”
A day into testing, an HS80 upgrader finds the A50 Gen 5 comfy with a great mic but zero passive noise blocking.
“the A50s have a great mic, but I can hear everything going on in the room”
A gamer swapped a wired audiophile setup for the A50 Gen 5 and finds the mic good enough to shelve their condenser.
“Swapped my HD6XX + SMSL M500 stack for the Astro A50 Gen 5s. Wireless is a lifesaver with a cable-chewing cat.”
After trying and returning many headsets including the Maxwell 1 and 2 and Nova Pro, a gamer keeps coming back to the A50 Gen 5.
“I keep coming back to the A50 gen 5’s. They just do everything I need well.”
With parametric EQ, a gamer finds the A50 Gen 5 a beast for sound with a top mic, comfortable for 4-5+ hours.
“A50gen5 +parametric EQ is a beast of sound also microphone quality is king and most importantly comfortable enough makes go over 4-5 + hours no problem.”
Moving from the Maxwell 1 to the A50 Gen 5, a gamer found music noticeably worse but gaming even, and preferred the A50's mic.
“I used the Maxwell 1s and swapped to the A50 gen 5 and notice a pretty big difference music wise.”
After owning several Turtle Beach and SteelSeries headsets, a user finds the Astro A50 Gen 5 the best for comfort and sound on console.
“The astro a50 gen 5 are by far the best headset I have had for comfort and sound bare in mind this is for xbox series x or playststion 5”
A user found the Astro A50 Gen 5 fun-sounding with great imaging but returned it because the pads were too small.
“The astro A50 gen 5 actually sound good and super fun, great imaging. I returned them only because the pads were too small for my ears even with Wickeds”
After owning the Nova Elite and Maxwell 2, a user went back to the Astro A50 Gen 5 for its mic and comfort.
“I’ve had the nova elite and maxwell 2 with no hissing issue but eventually went back to astro a50 gen5. It has the best mic and comfort between the 2”
A user's Astro A50 Gen 5 had repeated problems in PS5 party chat, so they're replacing it.
“I bought the **Astro A50 Gen 5**, but unfortunately I’ve had all kinds of problems with them specifically in **PS5 party voice chat**”
An owner calls the Astro A50 Gen 5 an amazing pick for the price, despite annoyances with the base station and docking.
“Imo even in 2026 I find the A50 Gen 5s an amazing pick for the current price. It offers a lot, however there are some pained grievances that also make me not touch mine as much.”
With aftermarket pads, a user finds the Astro A50 Gen 5 sounds and feels amazing.
“I recently got Astro a50 gen 5s with wicked cushions stealthz pad it’s bigger than the stock pad and sounds and feels amazing”
After trying several headsets, a user kept the Astro A50 Gen 5 for comfort, sound, EQ and the best mic.
“I stuck with the Astros because of the feeling on my big ass head, the sound was better than all the other ones, the eq was better imo. The mic is by far the best one as well.”
A user who tried the Logitech G Astro A50 Gen 5 found it decent but felt cheap compared with older Astros.
“Yes, actually. They’re pretty decent as well. I just feel like the others on this list eclipse it for different reasons.”
Owns the Maxwell, A50 Gen 5 and Nova Elite: the A50 has the best mic and comfort but the worst noise rejection.
“For mic quality the A50 is a clear winner, but the worst noise rejection”
Very happy with the Astro A50 Gen 5 after returning a Nova 7 Gen 2.
“Returned them and got the Logitech Astro A50 gen 5 and I'm very happy with them.”
Found the A50 Gen 5 fantastic except for top-of-head pressure from the headband.
“The A50 is fantastic. The only issue was the fit and the pressure from the top headband.”
Kept the Astro A50 Gen 5 for its good sound, but it doesn't get very loud and feels heavy on long sessions.
“I’ve kept hold of the Astro’s so far as the sound quality is good but they don’t get that loud and I find them heavy on long sessions”
They use it with PC, PS5 Pro and Switch 2 and call it great value with a really good mic.
“Astro A50 Gen 5 is probably the best bang for your buck anyone of the best wireless gaming headsets with a really good mic.”
They returned two pairs of the Gen 5 because the sidetone was far too weak compared with their Gen 4.
“I’ve returned two pairs of gen 5’s due to the side tone being terribly weak.”